Start with the size of the problem
A website makeover and a website rebuild solve different kinds of problems. A makeover makes targeted improvements to an existing site. A rebuild replaces or substantially recreates the site when the existing structure, content or technology no longer fits what the business needs.
The right choice depends on the actual condition of the site, not simply its age.
Signs a website makeover may be enough
A makeover may make sense when the basic website still works and the problems are limited. Examples include:
- A small number of broken links or buttons.
- Minor spacing, image or layout problems.
- Several mobile display issues.
- Outdated wording or headings on otherwise useful pages.
- Navigation that needs modest cleanup.
- Basic on-page SEO elements that need review.
These are the kinds of targeted issues my Website Makeover service is designed to review and address within the scope of the selected package.
Signs a rebuild may make more sense
A larger rebuild may be more appropriate when the problem is not limited to a few corrections. Examples can include:
- Most pages need substantial restructuring.
- The website no longer represents the current business.
- Major new functionality is required.
- The current platform or setup cannot reasonably support the required changes.
- The navigation and page structure need to be reorganized throughout the site.
- Fixing the existing site would effectively mean recreating most of it.
There is no universal number of problems that automatically turns a makeover into a rebuild. The scope and type of the problems matter more than a simple count.
Appearance alone should not decide it
An old-looking site may still have a sound structure that can be improved. A modern-looking site can have deeper problems with navigation, content, mobile usability or customer paths. Evaluate how the site works as well as how it looks.
Consider whether the business itself has changed
If the business now offers different services, serves a different area or needs the website to accomplish something completely different, editing the old pages one at a time may not be the most practical approach.
Check whether the important parts still work
Look at the main navigation, contact paths, forms, buttons, service pages and mobile layouts. If the underlying structure works and the problems are isolated, targeted fixes may be reasonable. If problems repeat across most of the site, the project may be larger.
What happens if I buy a makeover and the site needs rebuilding?
Under my current Website Makeover service, if I determine that a full rebuild is needed instead of a makeover, the makeover payment can be credited toward a new Toohey Services website according to the terms shown on the service page. Review the current Website Makeover options and conditions before purchasing.
Still unsure?
You do not need to diagnose every technical problem yourself. If the website is basically usable but has a handful of issues, start by identifying what is bothering you most. If nearly everything feels wrong, a broader review may be more useful before deciding how much to change.